Final answer:
The unidentified element is most likely beryllium (Be) as it belongs to the alkaline earth metal group, has similar properties to magnesium and strontium, and has a lower atomic mass than both.
Step-by-step explanation:
The most likely identity of the unidentified element with similar properties to magnesium and strontium but with a lower atomic mass is beryllium (Be). Beryllium belongs to the alkaline earth metal group, just like magnesium and strontium, and has a lower atomic mass than both of them.
Beryllium (atomic number 4) has 4 electrons in its outermost energy level, with the electron configuration [He]2s². Similarly, magnesium (atomic number 12) has 2 more electrons in its outermost energy level, and its electron configuration is [Ne]3s². Strontium (atomic number 38), on the other hand, has 6 more electrons in its outermost energy level, with the electron configuration [Kr]5s².
Therefore, based on the given information, the unidentified element with similar properties to magnesium and strontium but with a lower atomic mass is most likely beryllium (Be).