150k views
5 votes
We noted on the first page of the chapter that humans vary considerably in height. State a hypothesis about whether this reflects genetic variation, environmental variation, or genotype-by-environment interaction (any hypothesis is okay). What kinds of evidence might settle the question? Are there experiments that, at least in prin- ciple, would decide the matter? Would it be easier to do them with another species, such as mice?

1 Answer

0 votes

Final answer:

A hypothesis might suggest that the variation in human height is due to both genetic variation and environmental factors. Evidence for this could come from twin and genetic studies, as well as controlled experiments with other species like mice, though translating findings across species must be done with caution.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question revolves around forming a hypothesis about whether the variation in human height is due to genetic variation, environmental variation, or a combination of both, known as genotype-by-environment interaction.

Exploring the Hypothesis

A hypothesis addressing this question could be that the variation in human height is primarily due to genetic differences among individuals, but is also significantly influenced by environmental factors such as nutrition and lifestyle. To settle this question, we would look for evidence that can distinguish between the genetic and environmental contributions to height.

Evidence and Experiments

The types of evidence that could contribute to answering this include twin studies, where identical twins raised in different environments can shed light on the nature vs nurture debate. Moreover, genetic studies could identify specific height-associated alleles and their prevalence in different populations. Finally, longitudinal studies tracking height in relation to changing environmental conditions can offer insight into the environmental influences on height.

Experimental studies with other species, such as mice, can be more straightforward due to the possibility of controlled breeding and environment settings. Nonetheless, ethical and practical implications need to be considered when transferring conclusions from one species to another.

User Joel Kinzel
by
7.6k points