182k views
1 vote
According to lecture, what is the most likely solution for the 'accuracy problem' of historical Delphic oracles."

a. Using modern technology for reinterpretation.
b. Ignoring the oracles as unreliable.
c. Consulting alternative oracles for confirmation.
d. Relying on written records for accuracy.

User Steveng
by
7.2k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The most likely solution for the 'accuracy problem' of historical Delphic oracles is to rely on written records for accuracy, supplemented by modern critical analysis and comparative study. This method counteracts issues of memory distortion and biased compilation in sacred texts.

Step-by-step explanation:

The most likely solution for the 'accuracy problem' of historical Delphic oracles is to rely on written records for accuracy. This is because modern reinterpretation of the sacred texts may incorporate our contemporary understanding and methodologies. Furthermore, consulting alternative oracles could complicate matters with varied interpretations, and outright ignoring the oracles as unreliable does not solve the issue but rather sidesteps it. Relying on written records, especially those from near the time of the events, can offer the most direct lens into past occurrences and beliefs without as much alteration through the psychological problem of memory distortion or the textual problem of selective inclusion by religious leaders.Moreover, the details within these records can be crucial in understanding the contexts and potential biases of the sources. Academic analyses of such texts, informed by archeological data and historical context, can give us the clearest picture possible. An understanding that historical texts have been subject to selective inclusion and may reflect the biases of their compilers, requires a careful and critical approach to these sources. With modern historical analysis techniques, scholars can attempt to extract accurate historical information.In conclusion, although no method is without its flaws, the reliance on written records, supplemented by modern critical analysis and comparative study, offers the best potential solution for resolving the accuracy problem of historical Delphic oracles.

User Paul PUGET
by
7.9k points