Final answer:
High-scoring essays use evidence that is well-aligned with each claim and thoroughly analyzed. They engage the reader with captivating strategies while providing well-organized arguments that reflect a deep understanding of the subject matter and context.
Step-by-step explanation:
The use of evidence in high-scoring essays is distinct in its consistency and alignment with the paper's thesis and arguments. High-scoring essays are characterized by evidence that directly supports specific claims within each section or paragraph. For example, in stating that placing student seating closer to the basketball court will enhance players' performance, an effective essay would follow up with evidence such as studies showing how increased fan support boosts player morale and leads to better play. This supportive evidence is neatly organized, with each piece of evidence reinforcing the claim it follows.
Beyond the organization of evidence, the strongest essays include analysis of each piece of evidence. Typically, including one quote or paraphrase per paragraph followed by 2-3 sentences of analysis ensures each piece of evidence contributes to the overall argument. If during the writing process some evidence no longer aligns with the evolving thesis, flexibility is key—the writer must be willing to adapt their argument and remove evidence that no longer fits.
Highly effective essays engage the reader with various strategies, such as thought-provoking questions, intriguing statistics, and detailed anecdotes, which not only maintain interest but also enrich the reader's understanding. Moreover, a sophisticated essay acknowledges the cultural context and showcases a nuanced understanding of the subject matter through polished language and clear organization. When comparing and contrasting texts, the best essays utilize identified similarities and differences to make a larger argument about the texts in question.