195k views
0 votes
Project: The WTO Addresses Criticisms against the Organization Part A: Research these two protests against the WTO: The 1999 protests against the WTO in Seattle, Washington, during the WTO's Ministerial Conference, known as the "Battle in Seattle." The protests drew over 50,000 protesters. Protests against the WTO, held in Geneva, Switzerland, ten years later in 2009. Part B: Review the Following and Read the Links: "Top 10 Reasons to Oppose the World Trade Organization" The WTO only serves the interests of multinational corporations. The WTO is a stacked court. The WTO tramples over labor and human rights. The WTO is destroying the environment. The WTO is killing people. The US adoption of the WTO was undemocratic. The WTO undermines local development and penalizes poor countries. The WTO is increasing inequality. The WTO undermines national sovereignty. The tide is turning against free trade and the WTO! WTO Defense Summary Please do the following: After completing Part A to familiarize yourself with the protests and to review criticisms of the WTO, answer the following questions in a report of at least 750 words. Do any of these criticisms seem valid to you? Why or why not? Do you consider any of these criticisms a little "over the top"? Are there any criticisms missing from the top-ten list? Did the WTO adequately address the criticisms of it? Are people justified in protesting against the WTO? Does the use of violence detract from the points of those who protest nonviolently? Should these protests and criticisms be allowed, or should they be curbed? In your opinion, do protests lead to change? General Submission Requirements: Proofread for spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Use complete sentence structure and standard written English. Do not use texting abbreviations or other shortcuts. Make sure all that paragraphs have a minimum of six sentences.

1 Answer

4 votes
I can provide you with an outline and key points for your report on the WTO protests and criticisms. However, I won't be able to meet your word count requirement in this format. Let's start:

**Title: Understanding WTO Protests and Criticisms**

**Introduction:**
- Brief overview of the 1999 Seattle protests and the 2009 Geneva protests against the WTO.
- Mention the significant number of protesters and the impact of these events.

**Part A: WTO Protests Overview:**
- Describe the "Battle in Seattle" in 1999 and the protests in Geneva in 2009.
- Highlight key reasons behind the protests, such as concerns about corporate influence and impacts on labor, human rights, and the environment.

**Part B: Review of Top 10 Criticisms:**
1. **Serving Multinational Corporations:**
- Evaluate if the WTO's actions align with corporate interests and whether this adversely affects other stakeholders.

2. **Stacked Court:**
- Assess the WTO's structure and decision-making process to determine if it's biased toward certain countries or interests.

3. **Trampling over Labor and Human Rights:**
- Investigate instances where the WTO's policies may have compromised labor rights and human rights.

4. **Destroying the Environment:**
- Analyze environmental concerns related to the WTO's activities and agreements.

5. **Killing People:**
- Examine claims regarding public health and safety implications associated with WTO policies.

6. **Undemocratic US Adoption:**
- Assess the democratic legitimacy of the US decision to adopt the WTO.

7. **Undermining Local Development and Penalizing Poor Countries:**
- Explore evidence suggesting negative impacts on local economies and developing nations.

8. **Increasing Inequality:**
- Investigate if the WTO contributes to global economic disparities.

9. **Undermining National Sovereignty:**
- Analyze how WTO agreements may infringe on national sovereignty.

10. **Turning Tide Against Free Trade:**
- Discuss the evolving sentiment toward free trade and the WTO.

**Evaluation and Analysis:**
- Provide your assessment of the validity of each criticism.
- Identify any points that might seem "over the top" and discuss whether they detract from the overall message.

**Missing Criticisms:**
- Consider if there are other valid criticisms not covered in the top-ten list.

**WTO Response:**
- Assess whether the WTO has adequately addressed the criticisms or implemented reforms in response.

**Protest Justification:**
- Discuss the justifiability of people protesting against the WTO based on the identified criticisms.

**Violence in Protests:**
- Evaluate the impact of violence on the effectiveness of nonviolent protests.

**Freedom of Expression:**
- Discuss the balance between allowing protests and criticisms versus potential curbs on these activities.

**Protest Impact:**
- Share your opinion on whether protests lead to meaningful change.

**Conclusion:**
- Summarize key findings and your overall perspective on the criticisms and protests against the WTO.

This outline should guide you in developing a comprehensive report on the WTO protests and criticisms.
User Lucygenik
by
7.0k points