97.9k views
3 votes
A group of students go on an outdoor activity holiday. Each student chooses one activity from swimming

1) swimming
2) hiking
3) camping
4) biking

User Run CMD
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Anastasia, Emma, and Greta's preferences create a voting cycle where there is no clear winner among mountain biking, canoeing, and the beach, making a unanimous decision hard to attain.

Step-by-step explanation:

The issue presented centers on a voting cycle within a group decision-making scenario. Anastasia, Emma, and Greta each have a different set of preferences for their weekend getaway activities, resulting in a situation where no single activity is the definitive group favorite. They prefer mountain biking over canoeing by a 2-1 vote, canoeing over the beach by the same margin, but then the beach trumps mountain biking in a head-to-head contest, also by a 2-1 vote.

This outcome illustrates a non-transitive voting cycle where the collective preference isn't transitive — i.e., if A is preferred over B, and B is preferred over C, it does not mean A is necessarily preferred over C. The impossibility of a transitive group preference makes reaching a unanimous decision very challenging. For instance, even though mountain biking is preferred to canoeing, and canoeing is preferred to the beach, the group paradoxically prefers the beach over mountain biking.

User Alex KeySmith
by
7.8k points