220k views
5 votes
From an ethical standpoint, in what way is researching prisoners with tuberculosis similar to researching children with ADHD?

Select one:
a. Both groups of participants have less autonomy than other types of participants.
b. Researchers do not have to have written informed consent with these groups of participants.
c. Neither group of participants can provide informed consent.
d. Researchers must ensure anonymity when dealing with both types of participants.

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Both researching prisoners with tuberculosis and children with ADHD involves participants with reduced autonomy, making informed consent a critical ethical issue. The historical precedent of the Tuskegee experiment underlines the significance of ensuring voluntary and informed participation in research. It's crucial for ethical standards to be diligently applied to protect the interests and rights of vulnerable populations in research.

Step-by-step explanation:

From an ethical standpoint, researching prisoners with tuberculosis is similar to researching children with ADHD because both groups of participants have less autonomy than other types of participants. Individuals in both cohorts may not be fully capable of providing informed consent due to their circumstances - prisoners potentially facing coercion through incentives and children being legally incompetent to make such decisions by virtue of their age. In both cases, it is imperative to ensure that proper safeguards are in place, such as obtaining consent from a legal guardian in the case of children, and providing genuinely voluntary participation options for prisoners without undue incentives that could compromise consent.

These ethical concerns align with historical instances like the Tuskegee experiment, where the affected population was misinformed, emphasizing the importance of informed consent. Similarly, the necessary procedures outlined by Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) enforce ethical guidelines for conducting research, ensuring that consent is both informed and voluntary.

User Blacharnia
by
8.9k points