Final answer:
Lily thinks that Gabriel has the same birth mother as Jonas.
Step-by-step explanation:
In Lois Lowry's novel "The Giver," Lily, an innocent and curious character, innocuously speculates about Gabriel and Jonas sharing the same birth mother. This conjecture arises from Lily's limited understanding of the concept of birth mothers and birth-givers, which are carefully managed in their controlled society. Her assumption lacks concrete evidence or a deep comprehension of the complex societal structures that dictate births and family arrangements in their community. Her innocent speculation, more a reflection of childhood curiosity than an informed conclusion, underlines the lack of information and openness in their society, where such details are intentionally obscured or controlled.
Lily's speculation is based on her observations and limited understanding of the world around her. Being a young and naive character, she doesn't possess the knowledge or comprehension to decipher the intricate rules and regulations governing births and familial connections. Her conjecture highlights the underlying mystery and concealed truths in their community, emphasizing the prevalent lack of transparency regarding family structures and origins. It also illustrates the innocence and simplicity of childhood curiosity, as Lily innocently attempts to make sense of a society shrouded in secrets and restrictions.