222k views
2 votes
When one prisoner is hanged for stealing, two other prisoners assist in his hanging. Why do the two prisoners help the guards hang him? What does this suggest about the prisoner's humanity?

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The two prisoners assist in the hanging because of a dilemma they face in the prisoner's dilemma scenario, and it suggests that their humanity is influenced by the incentives and consequences they face.

Step-by-step explanation:

The situation you are describing is known as the prisoner's dilemma, which is a concept in game theory commonly used in social studies. In this scenario, the two prisoners assist the guards in hanging the third prisoner because they face a dilemma between cooperating and betraying each other. If both prisoners remain silent and cooperate, they would only serve a total of four years in jail. However, if one prisoner confesses or betrays the other, they can potentially get a lighter sentence. This suggests that the prisoners' humanity is influenced by the incentives and consequences they face, leading to a difficult decision where they prioritize their own self-interest over their solidarity as prisoners.

User Shahid Hamdam
by
7.6k points