94.3k views
4 votes
A wristwatch suddenly stops working. After replacing the battery, the watch starts working again. Which of the following statements correctly describes the situation from the perspective of the scientific method?

a) This proves that a dead battery was the reason the wristwatch stopped working
b) This substantiates the theory that all wristwatches require functional batteries
c) This is consistent with the hypothesis that a dead battery caused the wristwatch to stop working.
d) This leads to the prediction that a battery is required for wristwatch operation.

User Ankimal
by
8.4k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The correct interpretation of the situation from the perspective of the scientific method is 'c) This is consistent with the hypothesis that a dead battery caused the wristwatch to stop working.' This suggests the observation supports the hypothesis but is not definitive proof.

Step-by-step explanation:

When a wristwatch stops working and begins to function again after replacing the battery, the best scientific interpretation is c) This is consistent with the hypothesis that a dead battery caused the wristwatch to stop working. This phraseology suggests that the observation provides support for the hypothesis but does not conclusively prove it, recognizing that other factors could potentially cause the watch to stop working. This is how the scientific method typically proceeds: through incremental support for hypotheses rather than definitive proof from a single observation.

It is important to note that while statement b) This substantiates the theory that all wristwatches require functional batteries is a broader principle likely to be true, the incident with the watch does not by itself substantiate a universal theory for all wristwatches. Similarly, while statement d) This leads to the prediction that a battery is required for wristwatch operation may seem like a reasonable conclusion, it is better specified as an inference or an implication rather than a prediction. Statement a), on the other hand, mistakenly implies conclusive proof (proves) which is not accurate in the realm of the scientific method.

User Monitorjbl
by
8.7k points