234k views
4 votes
You should consider both:

A)intended propsal consequences
B)unintended consequences
C) intended and unintended consequences
D) no consequences at all

User First Zero
by
8.0k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

In engineering and policymaking, it is essential to consider both intended proposal consequences and unintended consequences of any action to ensure responsible and ethical decision-making. The complexity of engineered systems and the ethical approach of utilitarianism necessitate a consideration of all potential impacts, regardless of the agent's intentions. Assessing and mitigating possible harms are crucial when effects are not entirely predictable.

Step-by-step explanation:

When evaluating the consequences of an engineering solution, it is critical to consider all potential outcomes, including both intended proposal consequences and unintended consequences. The development of automobiles is an example of engineering that had the intended consequence of improving transportation but also led to unintended consequences such as air pollution and urban sprawl. Exploring the comprehensive impact of actions, including positive and negative externalities, is essential to responsible decision-making in engineering.

One must also consider the ethical perspective of consequentialism, specifically utilitarianism, which implies that the rightness of an action is determined solely by its outcomes for all those impacted, regardless of the intent or character of the agent. This has critical implications for policymaking and engineering practices, where even actions with noble intentions can lead to negative outcomes, such as genetically modified corn seed dispersing beyond intended fields.

Therefore, in any engineering activity, it is necessary to assess and mitigate possible harms, particularly when dealing with complex systems and environmental impacts, epitomized by the principle that one must proceed cautiously when the effects of an activity are not fully understood.

User SUDO Los Angeles
by
7.7k points