11.9k views
0 votes
The Heckscher-Ohlin model is good at projecting inter-industry trade patterns between countries where factors of production are different, but it fails when these differences are small or non-existent.

(A) Show using a general equilibrium or partial equilibrium diagram why H−O fails to predict trade patterns between two countries that have identical factor endowments and identical tastes. Technology should also be kept the same in your illustration.
(B) The US and Europe are two trading entities that have similar factor endowments and GDP and yet trade heavily with each other.
(i) Show diagrammatically - using a different partial or general equilibrium diagram- how under circumstances and assumptions from those in part (a), the US and Europe benefit from trade with each other even if they are assumed identical in every respect.
(ii) Explain the trade theory and its ingredients that supports your answer.

User Cporte
by
8.3k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The Heckscher-Ohlin (H-O) model fails to predict trade patterns between two countries with identical factor endowments, tastes, and technology. However, even when two countries have similar factor endowments, they can still benefit from trade through specialization and economies of scale.

Step-by-step explanation:

(A) The Heckscher-Ohlin (H-O) model predicts trade patterns based on differences in factor endowments between countries. However, when two countries have identical factor endowments, tastes, and technology, the H-O model fails to predict trade patterns. This can be illustrated using a partial equilibrium diagram. In this diagram, we will have two countries, A and B, with identical factor endowments and tastes. The production possibilities frontier (PPF) for each country will be a straight line, indicating constant opportunity costs. Since both countries have the same production capabilities, their PPFs will be identical and they will produce the same goods. With no differences in factor endowments or technology, there is no basis for trade, as both countries can produce all goods at the same cost.

(B) However, in reality, even when two countries have similar factor endowments, they can still benefit from trade with each other. This can be illustrated using a general equilibrium diagram. In this diagram, we will have the US and Europe as two trading entities with similar factor endowments and GDP. Despite these similarities, there can still be gains from trade. Specialization and economies of scale can lead to increased efficiency and lower production costs. For example, the US might have a comparative advantage in producing aircraft, while Europe might have a comparative advantage in producing automobiles. By specializing in the production of these goods and trading with each other, both regions can benefit from the gains of trade.

User Francesc Rosas
by
7.7k points