209k views
5 votes
Identify the truthfulness of the following statements:

The Condorcet paradox describes a situation in which social preferences contain a cycle.
The Condorcet paradox can only arise when at least one...

User Nmw
by
7.7k points

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

The statement that the Condorcet paradox describes a situation where social preferences form a cycle that prevents determining a majority favorite is true. Such a voting cycle exemplifies the paradox in a practical scenario, illustrating the challenges in collective decision-making.

Step-by-step explanation:

The Condorcet paradox describes a situation in which social preferences contain a cycle, revealing the complex dynamics of collective decision-making. This is a scenario where a majority of voters may prefer one option over a second, and the second over a third, but then paradoxically also prefer the third option over the first, leading to no clear majority favorite.

When discussing the truthfulness of statements, it is critical to recognize that despite differing beliefs, there is only one truth value to any fact or statement. The concept that a majority can prefer policy A to policy B, policy B to policy C, but also prefer policy C to policy A is true. This illustrates the Condorcet paradox, proving that majority preferences can be cyclic and inconsistent, which thwarts the process of reaching a conclusive majority decision in a vote.

The mention of the voting cycle in the provided text clearly supports the truthfulness of the statement about the Condorcet paradox. In such a cycle, where the group will vote for policy A over policy B by a certain ratio and form similar preferences for other policies, it becomes impossible to determine an overall majority favorite due to the cyclic nature of the preferences.

User Gyom
by
7.3k points