41.7k views
5 votes
RAND Health Insurance Experiment:

a) Explain one problem the RAND HIE was designed to address. Do you think the HIE sufficiently addressed this problem? Why or why not?
b) Explain one shortcoming of the RAND HIE and why it might affect our certainty in any conclusions we draw from the experiment’s results.
c) For a person who previously had no insurance, how would you expect their use to change for hospital care, dental care, and physician services if they were moved to a coinsurance rate of 25%? What about a coinsurance rate of 0%, relative to their use at the rate of 25%?

User Oniramarf
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

The RAND HIE was designed to address the problem of moral hazard in health insurance by studying the impact of cost-sharing arrangements on healthcare utilization and costs. While the experiment provided valuable insights, a shortcoming was the limited duration of follow-up. The use of healthcare services may change for a person without insurance when they are moved to a coinsurance rate of 25% or 0%.

Step-by-step explanation:

The RAND Health Insurance Experiment (HIE) was designed to address the problem of moral hazard in health insurance. Moral hazard occurs when individuals change their behavior as a result of having health insurance, leading to increased demand for healthcare services. The HIE aimed to study the impact of different cost-sharing arrangements, such as deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance, on healthcare utilization and costs.

While the RAND HIE provided valuable insights into the effects of cost-sharing on healthcare utilization, one shortcoming of the experiment was the limited duration of follow-up. The study followed participants for only three years, which may not capture the long-term effects of cost-sharing on healthcare outcomes.

If a person who previously had no insurance is moved to a coinsurance rate of 25%, their use of hospital care, dental care, and physician services may decrease compared to when they had no insurance. However, if the coinsurance rate is reduced to 0%, their use may increase. The level of coinsurance affects the financial burden individuals face when seeking healthcare services, which can impact their utilization patterns.

User Dwerner
by
8.3k points