Final answer:
The highest possible Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) when the largest dealer has a 12.5% market share would be 1250, and the four-firm concentration ratio would be 50%. If the top dealer has a 10% share, the highest HHI would be 1000, given similar market shares for the remaining firms.
Step-by-step explanation:
The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) and the four-firm concentration ratio are both measures of market concentration and competition. When the largest car dealer has 12.5% of the market, and all other dealers sell the same or fewer vehicles, the largest possible HHI occurs when each firm has an equal market share. With eight firms (100% / 12.5%), each would have a market share of 12.5%, and the HHI would be the sum of the square of each firm's market share in percentage terms, which is 8 * (12.5^2), giving an HHI of 1250. Conversely, the four-firm concentration ratio would be 4 * 12.5, resulting in 50%
For the second scenario, where the top dealer sells 10% of vehicles, the highest HHI would be achieved if there were ten firms each with 10% of the market. Thus, the HHI would be 10 * (10^2) = 1000. It's important to notice that both calculations are based on the assumption that the remaining firms have equal or smaller shares than the largest firm.