221k views
5 votes
Is the Virginian's type of justice justified in the novel?

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

In 'The Virginian,' the protagonist's concept of justice is seen through the lens of historical context and personal beliefs, reflecting a time when justice was not solely determined by codified law.

Step-by-step explanation:

The concept of justice in the novel The Virginian is complex and reflects the historical context and personal ethics of the characters rather than a modern understanding of legal justice. In the passage, the Virginian appears to distinguish between personal vengeance and what he sees as justice, suggesting a moral rationale for his actions despite them being "technically illegal".

This mirrors the historical attitudes where figures like George Fitzhugh defended slavery as a form of paternal care, and white Southerners justified violent acts like those of the Ku Klux Klan as necessary responses to political challenges. It is a reflection of the times when individual notions of right and wrong were strongly influenced by personal beliefs and social norms rather than strictly codified laws that we understand today.

User Mannok
by
7.8k points