Final answer:
All the hydrogen in the universe was formed during the Big Bang, not in stars or supernovae. Stars later utilized hydrogen to create heavier elements through nuclear fusion reactions in their cores.
Step-by-step explanation:
The hydrogen in the universe was primarily formed during the Big Bang, at the very beginning of the universe. After the Big Bang, there was a period of rapid expansion and cooling, which allowed the first subatomic particles to form. These particles then combined to create hydrogen nuclei. The creation of hydrogen gave way to the initial fuel for stars, where further nuclear reactions such as hydrogen burning occurs, fusing hydrogen into helium. This process contributes to stellar evolution and the formation of elements beyond lithium, which generally occurs in the fiery cores of stars or the explosive ends of their life cycles, known as supernovae.
Therefore, the correct answer to where all the hydrogen in the universe was formed is D) in the Big Bang, at the very beginning of the universe. While stars are responsible for the creation of heavier elements through the process of stellar nucleosynthesis, the majority of hydrogen was already present from the early moments of the universe's history.