136k views
4 votes
A major criticism of Freud's theory is that it _____.

A. is refuted by many modern research studies
B. suggests the existence of the displacement defense mechanism
C. makes constant reference to the unconscious
D. is not comprehensive enough

User ScootyPuff
by
8.0k points

2 Answers

3 votes

Answer:

Step-by-step explanation:

The major criticism of Freud's theory is that it:

A. is refuted by many modern research studies.

User Squarebrackets
by
8.4k points
4 votes

Final answer:

A major criticism of Freud's theory is its non-falsifiability, meaning that core concepts like the id, ego, and superego cannot be tested empirically. Post-structuralist and feminist critiques also target the lack of empirical observation and patriarchal biases in his work. Despite the criticisms, Freud's legacy in understanding the unconscious mind remains influential in psychology.

Step-by-step explanation:

A major criticism of Freud's theory is that it is not falsifiable. Freud's concepts such as the id, ego, and superego are integral to his theory of psychoanalysis but pose a challenge for empirical validation. His idea that most of our mind's activity, including thoughts, feelings, and memories, are unconscious and that the unconscious mind has a substantial influence on our behavior is difficult to test or observe scientifically. Additionally, Freud's suggestions that early childhood experiences significantly impact the adult personality and that dreams offer insights into the unconscious are contested as they are not empirically verifiable.

While Freud's theories remain historically significant and have set the foundation for various aspects of modern psychology and therapy, the non-falsifiable nature of many of his ideas has led to substantial criticism. Post-structuralists and feminists have also critiqued his theories for different reasons, including the claim that psychoanalysis cannot be empirically observed and its perceived patriarchal biases.

Despite the fact that Freud's specific hypotheses lack empirical support in modern research, his contribution to understanding the importance of the unconscious mind in human thought and behavior cannot be denied. The discussions around the veracity of Freud's theories continue to influence psychological thinking and practices today.

User David DIVERRES
by
7.6k points