Question

A client with newly diagnosed breast cancer asks the nurse, "Why me? I've always been a good person. What have I done to deserve this?" Which response by the nurse would be most therapeutic?

1. "Don't worry. You'll probably live longer than I will."




2. "I'm sure a cure will be found soon."




3. "You seem upset. Let's talk about something happy."




4. "Would you like to talk about this?"

Answer 1

The most therapeutic response for a nurse to provide to a client with newly diagnosed breast cancer who asks why they deserve it is to offer a listening ear and support.

Step-by-step explanation:

The most therapeutic response for a nurse to provide to a client with newly diagnosed breast cancer who asks, 'Why me? I've always been a good person. What have I done to deserve this?' is option 4: 'Would you like to talk about this?'. This response acknowledges the client's feelings and invites open communication, giving the client an opportunity to express their emotions and concerns. It shows empathy and demonstrates that the nurse is willing to listen and support the client through their emotional journey.

Answer 2

"Navigating a diagnosis like this can be incredibly difficult, and it's natural to wonder why it's happening to you. Cancer doesn't discriminate based on who deserves it or not. It's important to focus on the support and care you need right now to help you through this challenging time."

Step-by-step explanation:

When faced with a profound question like "Why me?", the nurse's response should aim to acknowledge the emotional distress while providing a supportive and compassionate perspective. Cancer isn't a punishment or a result of deserving or undeserving actions. It's crucial to emphasize that anyone, regardless of their character or actions, can be affected by it. This response seeks to validate the client's feelings while redirecting focus towards the necessary care and support.

The emotional impact of a cancer diagnosis can be overwhelming. It's vital for healthcare professionals to show empathy and understanding. While the mathematical calculations aren't applicable in this context, the calculation involved in addressing this question lies in the delicate balance of validating the client's feelings without reinforcing any notions of blame or guilt.

The approach centers on emotional support rather than factual reasoning, highlighting the importance of empathy and compassion in healthcare communication. The nurse's response aims to provide comfort and encouragement to the client, helping them focus on receiving necessary care and support during this challenging time.

The approach centers on emotional support rather than factual reasoning, highlighting the importance of empathy and compassion in healthcare communication. The nurse's response aims to provide comfort and encouragement to the client, helping them focus on receiving necessary care and support during this challenging time.