38.2k views
3 votes
Give a vertebrate example of a non-monophyletic group. What is wrong with recognizing non-monophyletice groups?

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

A non-monophyletic vertebrate group example is reptiles when excluding birds, which creates an inaccurate evolutionary picture. Recognizing non-monophyletic groups, like non-vascular plants, overlooks common ancestors and shared traits, leading to potential confusion in understanding relatedness and evolution.

Step-by-step explanation:

An example of a vertebrate that is part of a non-monophyletic group would be reptiles, if we exclude birds. Birds are descended from theropod dinosaurs, which are traditional members of the reptilian clade, so if birds are left out, the group is non-monophyletic. The problem with recognizing non-monophyletic groups is that they do not accurately represent evolutionary histories as these groups combine organisms without including all descendents of a common ancestor.

Non-monophyletic, or paraphyletic groups, like non-vascular plants (mosses, liverworts, and hornworts), do not provide a clear and accurate depiction of evolutionary relatedness which is essential for understanding the biological diversity and the evolutionary history. These groupings can be misleading because they may group species together based on missing features (e.g., absence of a vascular system) rather than shared derived traits.

Thus, classifying organisms into monophyletic groups that include all the descendants of a single common ancestor provides a clearer and more scientific understanding of their relationships and evolution, which is essential for various fields like taxonomy, phylogenetics, and biodiversity studies.

User Jack Desert
by
8.3k points