Question

Sartre argues that we create our essence almost entirely - even to the point that our central career activity is up to us. Beauvoir argues that there are many cases in which a person's freedom to have a particular career depends in large part on the choices of others. Discuss one example and explain how it amounts to a criticism of Sartre's view that we are radically free to craft our essence.

Answer 1

One example of how a person's freedom to have a particular career depends on the choices of others is in the field of medicine, specifically surgery. This example criticizes Sartre's view of radical freedom by highlighting the interdependence and reliance on others in career paths.

Step-by-step explanation:

One example of how a person's freedom to have a particular career depends on the choices of others can be seen in the field of medicine. For instance, if a person wants to become a surgeon, they would require the support and cooperation of other healthcare professionals, such as nurses and anesthesiologists, in order to perform surgeries safely and effectively. Without the collaboration and cooperation of these individuals, the surgeon would not be able to fulfill their career aspirations.

This example criticizes Sartre's view of radical freedom, as it highlights the interdependence and reliance on others that exists in many career paths. It shows that our ability to pursue a specific career is not solely determined by our own choices, but also depends on the choices and actions of others.