Avery's parrot training involves an independent variable of reinforcement or punishment for Sigmund and Watson. The dependent variable is the number of correct lyrics. Ethically, positive reinforcement for Sigmund is sound, but mild shocks for Watson raise concerns. Statistical analysis reveals Sigmund's mean correct behaviors at 2.5 and Watson's at 1. Positive reinforcement strengthens Sigmund's learning, while Watson's shocks may lead to learned helplessness, impacting his well-being and raising ethical considerations.
Part A: Relating Concepts
Independent variable: In Avery's training, the independent variable is the type of reinforcement or punishment given to the parrots. Sigmund receives positive reinforcement (treats) for approximating the correct lyrics and additional treats for completing the entire song correctly every third time. Watson, on the other hand, experiences positive punishment (mild shock) when he sings the wrong lyrics.
Dependent variable: The dependent variable is the number of correctly completed lyrics. It is what Avery measures to assess the effectiveness of the training methods for each parrot.
Ethical treatment of subjects: This pertains to how Avery treats her parrots during training. Using positive reinforcement for Sigmund is ethically sound as it encourages desired behavior without harm. However, using mild shocks for Watson raises ethical concerns, as it involves subjecting the parrot to discomfort.
Part B: Statistical Procedures
Mean correct behaviors:
For Sigmund: (1 + 2 + 3 + 4) / 4 = 2.5
For Watson: (2 + 1 + 0 + 1) / 4 = 1
Bar graph:
The x-axis represents parrots (Sigmund and Watson), and the y-axis represents the mean correct behaviors.
Part C: Relating Concepts
Positive reinforcement: Sigmund's training involves positive reinforcement, where a treat is given for correct approximations and additional treats for completing the entire song correctly. This strengthens the association between singing correctly and receiving rewards, promoting desired behavior.
Learned Helplessness: Watson's exposure to mild shocks when singing incorrectly may lead to learned helplessness. If Watson perceives the shocks as uncontrollable and unrelated to his behavior, he might become passive and helpless, assuming there's no way to avoid the discomfort, potentially hindering his learning and performance. This method raises ethical concerns as well.