Final answer:
The most effective feedback for a creative writing student is specific and constructive, focusing on particular story elements that need clarity or further development, such as character motivations or the significance of the setting. The correct responce would be I was left wondering why the main character chose not to go home at the end.
Step-by-step explanation:
Comparing the different types of feedback given to a creative writing student, the most effective feedback is an inquiry into specific aspects of the story that left the reader questioning. For instance, saying I was left wondering why the main character chose not to go home at the end provides a targeted opportunity for the author to reflect on their narrative choices and consider whether this aspect of the story needs further development. Effective feedback often entails highlighting areas where the reader needs more information or clarity, like pinpointing the significance of a story's setting, the development of the plot, the depth of characters, and the use of figurative language.
Advising to change the entire setting lacks specificity, and saying one does not like stories with unanswered questions is more an opinion than constructive criticism. However, proposing to give the main character more lines of dialogue could be constructive if it's aimed at improving character development or clarifying plot points.