51.9k views
0 votes
Independence of central bank is very crucial for impartial functioning and fair play in the economy. Any closeness of central bank to ministry of finance will not be fair and it will be viewed as baby of the government and will be looked with suspicion. Do you agree or disagree with the above statement and what is your stand?

1) Agree
2) Disagree

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

I agree that central bank independence is crucial for ensuring impartial and effective monetary policy, protecting the economy from politically-driven, short-term interference that can lead to inflation and economic instability. The ability of central banks to operate autonomously allows for rapid responses to economic situations, and historical data supports lower inflation rates in countries with independent central banks.

Step-by-step explanation:

I agree with the statement that the independence of a central bank is crucial for impartial functioning and fair play in the economy. An independent central bank ensures that there is a nonpartisan approach to monetary policy and economic decisions, avoiding the pitfalls of short-sighted political interference. In the cases of interest rates and the exchange rate regime, the insulation from daily political pressures allows the central bank to make decisions that are in the best long-term interest of the economy, rather than decisions that are politically expedient.

A concerted movement has occurred globally where central banks are granted greater autonomy, as studies have shown a correlation between central bank independence and lower inflation without hampering GDP growth or increasing unemployment. The European Central Bank (ECB) and the U.S. Federal Reserve are prime examples of this practice, focusing on maintaining price stability and responding quickly to market dynamics without political influence tainting their decisions regarding monetary policies.

The ability for central banks to act swiftly and decisively without the delays that legislative processes typically entail is another strong argument for their independence. Moreover, history has shown that when the monetary policy is under direct control of legislatures or closely tied to political agendas, the outcome can often lead to an overly expansionary monetary policy and higher inflation. Hence, the independence of a central bank is a protective measure against such economic instability.

While economists do not have a final consensus on the exact role a central bank should play, varying from those who support inflation targeting to those favoring greater discretion in policy making, the general agreement is that central banks can significantly influence macroeconomic outcomes through their conduct of monetary policy, affecting aggregate demand and thus playing a crucial role in economic performance. This influence becomes more robust and credible when the central bank can resist political pressures and maintain focus on the economy's long-term health rather than short-term political gains.

User YohanRoth
by
7.6k points