22.2k views
3 votes
Ethan turned 16 and got his driver's license. His parents bought him a beater, but he has to buy his own gas and insurance. He mowed lawns all summer and has some money, but the cost of an insurance policy is super expensive. He went to a shoddy storefront and bought minimum liability, a high deductible, and no collision. When his mom and dad found out what he'd done, they were concerned. He can't understand why. According to the state, he has what he needs. It isn't fair for his parents to be advising him to get a better (more expensive policy). Or is it?

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Ethan's minimal auto insurance coverage meets legal requirements but may be insufficient for significant accidents, highlighting the importance of more comprehensive policies. Parents often recommend better insurance to protect against financial risks and considering Ethan's young age, it is financially wise to heed their advice.

Step-by-step explanation:

Ethan's situation illustrates the challenges young drivers face with auto insurance costs. Although he meets the legal requirements, his minimum liability, high deductible, and no collision coverage may not provide adequate protection in the event of an accident. Considering car insurance is designed to protect against significant financial loss due to accidents, opting for a more comprehensive policy might be advisable despite the higher cost. Moreover, insurance rates are influenced by multiple factors, including the driver's age, driving history, and the vehicle's safety rating. Therefore, it is understandable that Ethan's parents would advise investing in better insurance. Essentially, a good insurance policy mitigates financial risks in ways that the bare minimum coverage cannot. Take, for instance, the simplified example of a group of 100 drivers with varied risks leading to different costs from minor to major accidents. Without being able to identify which drivers will incur which costs, the group collectively covers the total, demonstrating the pooling of risk that insurance represents.

This emphasizes the importance of selecting an insurance policy that not only complies with state laws but also aligns with the financial realities of potentially having to cover significant damages post-accident, which a bare minimum policy might not cover, ultimately leading to much higher out-of-pocket expenses for Ethan.

User EliteTUM
by
8.1k points