Final answer:
To evaluate Mayer's summation, one must consider whether it effectively restates the thesis, summarizes evidence without introducing new material, and leaves a lasting impression.
Step-by-step explanation:
Making a judgement on Mayer's summation effectiveness involves analyzing the elements of a strong conclusion. An effective summation revisits the thesis, summarizing the key evidence, while also potentially providing a final thought or call to action. A conclusion should not merely repeat the thesis in a mechanical way but rather show its significance. It's also important not to introduce new material in the conclusion but rather to encapsulate the argument in a way that reinforces the writer's points, leaving the reader with a sense of completeness and something to consider.
Based on the provided information, to judge Mayer's summation one must look for these qualities: restatement of the thesis, summarization of evidence, significance, no new material, and leaving the reader with a final impression. If Mayer's conclusion incorporates these elements successfully, it can be considered effective.