178k views
1 vote
First read “I Have a Dream”, followed by “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”. In these texts Dr. King is writing for two different audiences. Who are the audiences? How does he change his argument for each audience? What pieces of his argument stay the same?

User Recluze
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Dr. King tailored his message to different audiences in his 'I Have a Dream' speech and 'Letter from a Birmingham Jail,' but his core argument for immediate action against racial injustice remained consistent across both texts.

Step-by-step explanation:

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. addressed two distinct audiences in his notable works “I Have a Dream” and “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”. In the “I Have a Dream” speech, his audience was primarily the 250,000 participants of the March on Washington and the wider American public, inclusive of all races, who watched the live broadcasts. This speech aimed to inspire and convince the nation of the urgent need for change in the face of racial injustice and create a compelling vision of racial harmony

In contrast, “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” was written to a narrower audience: eight white Alabama clergymen who had criticized the pace and tactics of the civil rights movement. In this letter, Dr. King's approach is more direct and confrontational, countering the clergymen's call for “peace and patience” by stressing the urgency for immediate action and the moral responsibility to oppose unjust laws. He appeals to their sense of justice and shared religious values, hoping to gain their support or at least tolerance for the cause.

Despite these different approaches, a core piece of Dr. King's argument remains the same: the demand for equal rights and an end to racial discrimination based on the immutable principle of justice. He consistently emphasizes the interconnectedness of all communities and the injustice of waiting for a ““more convenient season” for freedom, a point that resonates in both pieces of writing.

User Simon Groenewolt
by
7.3k points