91.6k views
5 votes
In the passage below from Uncle Tom's Cabin, the slave trader Haley talks about treatment of slave mothers and children.

I've seen 'em as would pull a woman's child out of her arms, and set him up to sell, and she screechin' like mad all the time;—very bad policy—damages the article—makes 'em quite unfit for service sometimes. I knew a real handsome gal once, in Orleans, as was entirely ruined by this sort o' handling. The fellow that was trading for her didn't want her baby; and she was one of your real high sort, when her blood was up. I tell you, she squeezed up her child in her arms, and talked, and went on real awful. It kinder makes my blood run cold to think on't; and when they carried off the child, and locked her up, she jest went ravin' mad, and died in a week. Clear waste, sir, of a thousand dollars, just for want of management,—there's where 't is. It's always best to do the humane thing, sir; that's been my
experience.

What is ironic about Haley's "humane" approach to taking slave children from their mothers?

Taking a child from its mother and selling it is brutally inhumane in itself.

More humane treatment is a better protection of the slaveholder's investment.

User Lives
by
7.6k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Haley's 'humane' treatment is presented ironically in 'Uncle Tom's Cabin' as his concern lies with maintaining slaves' value for sale rather than recognizing their natural rights and well-being.

Step-by-step explanation:

The irony of Haley's 'humane' approach to taking slave children from their mothers in 'Uncle Tom's Cabin' lies in his perception of what constitutes humane treatment. While Haley believes it is better business practice to separate families without cruelty in order to maintain the health and value of the 'articles'—his word for slaves—he fails to recognize the fundamental inhumanity of the act of selling humans. Thus, the irony is that Haley views 'humane' treatment solely in terms of economic benefit rather than the actual well-being and natural rights of the slaves, particularly the women and children.

User EliteRaceElephant
by
6.6k points