Question

Directions: Using the table, identify the logical fallacy present in the numbered sentences from the

speech. The logical fallacy reference sheet can be found below. Then, rewrite the sentence from the
speech so that it uses facts and evidence instead of flawed logic.
Fallacy #
(1-5) from
speech
above
Example
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
Logical Fallacy Used
(ad hominem, bandwagon,
hasty generalization, strawman, or
slippery slope)
false analogy
Being class president can't be any
different from being babysitting,
because I am in charge of others.
Rewrite the sentence without a logical fallacy.
(Replace the flawed logic with facts or evidence)
I have plenty of experience in leading with responsibility.
For example, I have been babysitting for one year and am
also president of the school recycling club.

Answer 1

The logical fallacy in the statement is a false analogy, which compares two dissimilar items. The sentence can be revised to demonstrate the leadership experience gained from babysitting as preparation for being class president.

Step-by-step explanation:

The logical fallacy used in the statement "Being class president can't be any different from being babysitting, because I am in charge of others" is a false analogy. This fallacy occurs when two items being compared are not sufficiently similar in the context of the argument being made. To rewrite the sentence without a logical fallacy, one might say: "I have gained valuable leadership experience through my role as a babysitter, where I am responsible for managing children's daily activities and ensuring their safety, which has helped prepare me for the responsibilities involved in being class president."