60.5k views
1 vote
Some scientists believe NYC skyscrapers were built according to the rock below the surface. Who do you agree with, and why? Could there be another explanation?

a) I agree with the scientists who believe the rock influenced skyscraper construction because it provides a solid foundation.
b) I agree with those who think it's a coincidence because it's a matter of tradition.
c) I'm undecided and think there might be other factors involved.
d) I agree with both perspectives as they could complement each other.

User Willhess
by
6.9k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The construction of NYC skyscrapers was significantly influenced by the sturdy rock formations beneath the city, in addition to factors like real estate value, engineering advances, and corporate prestige. These elements together have shaped the distinct skyline of New York City.

Step-by-step explanation:

It is evident that the geology of New York City has had a significant influence on the construction of its skyscrapers. The solid bedrock, namely the Manhattan Schist, provides a sturdy foundation that can support the immense weight of these tall structures. In other words, the underlying rock has a direct impact on the feasibility of building skyscrapers, which affirms the viewpoint of scientists who believe that the rock below the surface guided the construction of NYC's iconic skyline.

Beyond geological factors, other considerations, such as real estate value and engineering advancements like steel girders and passenger elevators, have also played critical roles. The emergence of skyscrapers was a response to the limited space in urban centers and the need to grow upwards rather than outwards. This upward growth was made attractive not only by the increasing cost of real estate but also by the response to zoning laws that required buildings to be set back as they rose, ensuring that light and air could still reach the streets below, as shown by the design of the Chrysler Building and Rockefeller Center. Moreover, skyscrapers serve as symbols of corporate prestige, a testament to their importance beyond mere office space.

Overall, while the geology has been a fundamental aspect in determining the construction of skyscrapers, we cannot overlook the role of innovation, zoning laws, and corporate representation in the evolution of New York City's skyline. These factors intertwine to create the unique architectural landscape of NYC.

User David Kaneda
by
8.3k points