29.9k views
1 vote
Results of the Civil War - Why were the poorest people forced to enlist in the army and how did this cause tension in NYC?

a) The poorest individuals were drafted due to a lack of alternatives, leading to unrest in NYC.
b) Economic hardship compelled the most impoverished to join the army, causing friction in New York City.
c) The army recruited the least wealthy citizens because they had no other prospects, leading to discord in NYC.
d) Poor people were conscripted into the military, resulting in discontent within New York City.

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The poorest were forced to enlist in the Civil War due to the draft, where the wealthy could avoid service by paying for substitutes—leading to the perception of it being "a rich man's war, but a poor man's fight." The tension from this inequality and racism towards African Americans culminated in the violent New York City Draft Riots of July 1863.

Step-by-step explanation:

The main reason the poorest individuals were forced to enlist in the Civil War was due to the Enrollment Act, also known as the draft, which was the first effort at conscription among the northern populace. Wealthy New Yorkers could evade service by paying a $300 fee to hire substitutes, a sum far beyond what working-class citizens could afford. This policy led to the perception of the Civil War as "a rich man's war, but a poor man's fight," causing significant tension and resentment among the less fortunate, particularly in New York City (NYC).

This built-up tension and inequality eventually exploded into the New York City Draft Riots in July 1863, one of the worst race riots in U.S. history. The riots were fed by racism and fear that freedmen would take the jobs of those conscripted, as well as anger towards the draft's unfairness towards poor white citizens. The violence primarily targeted African Americans and resulted in the destruction of property, including the burning of a black orphanage and over 200 related deaths. Ultimately, the federal government had to intervene to suppress the violence using Union soldiers freshly returned from Gettysburg.

User Oakbramble
by
7.5k points