149k views
3 votes
Do you believe those who created our early democracy in the 1780s would recognize our (the US's) democracy today? Why or why not? (make a claim and support your answer using at least 2 pieces of evidence.

User Idancali
by
8.2k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The creators of early American democracy would recognize the foundational republic structure but would be surprised by the expanded electorate and modern complexities such as technology's impact.

Step-by-step explanation:

The creators of early American democracy in the 1780s would find today's U.S. democracy both familiar and alien. On one hand, the fundamental structure they established, a republic where citizens elect representatives to govern on their behalf, remains intact. This mirrors the Roman concept of a representative democracy and keeps with the framers' intent to prevent "mob rule" by balancing majority influence with a system of checks and balances.However, the American democracy has evolved significantly since the 1780s. The size and diversity of the electorate have drastically increased, due to amendments that expanded voting rights to categories of people previously excluded, such as women and African Americans. Additionally, modern technology and the emergence of a global economy have transformed the issues and the scale at which government operates. American democracy has developed into a more inclusive system, but one facing challenges unforeseen by its founders such as the role of money in politics, the influence of social media on public opinion, and increased partisan polarization.In conclusion, early American democracy's creators would recognize the foundational principles at work, but they might be surprised at both the advancements and complications of its 21st-century incarnation.

User Systemhalted
by
8.1k points