81.0k views
2 votes
A student said, ‘This part of the story, where the men encounter the

Tyrannosaurus Rex, shows Eckels is right to panic. The Monster is terrifying!’
To what extent do you agree?
In your response, you could:
• consider your own impressions of Eckels’ reaction to the Tyrannosaurus Rex
• evaluate how the writer describes the Monster
• support your response with references to the text.

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

The extent to which one agrees that Eckels' panic when facing the Tyrannosaurus Rex is justified depends on the narrative context and the writer's descriptive skill. However, real-world paleontology suggests that the panic may be exaggerated, as T. rex was likely a brisk walker rather than a fast runner. Literary analysis also considers how fear advances the story's themes.

Step-by-step explanation:

To what extent I agree that the description of the Tyrannosaurus Rex in the story justifies Eckels’ reaction of panic can depend on individual interpretation of the text. However, from a factual standpoint, it is widely recognized that depictions of dinosaurs in popular media, such as the Jurassic Park series, have often been exaggerated for dramatic effect. For example, contrary to the high-speed chases shown in films, scientific evidence suggests that a T. rex was incapable of running and could at best move at a brisk pace. This could suggest that Eckels’ terror, while understandable in a fictional context, might be hyperbolic given our current understanding of dinosaur physiology.

The writer’s description of the 'Monster' in the text plays a significant role in justifying Eckels’ reaction. If the Tyrannosaurus Rex is portrayed with powerful sensory detail and uses elements of hyperbole, it could make the reader sympathize with Eckels’ fear. Descriptive language that evokes the fight-or-flight response, a biological reaction to perceived danger that includes a racing heart and rapid breathing, could further validate Eckels’ panic.

To evaluate the accuracy of Eckels’ reaction and the description of the T. rex, it is valuable to compare the story’s portrayal to scientific evidence, such as that from the PaleobioDB Navigator or modern understandings of the fight-or-flight response. Nonetheless, in a purely literary analysis, it is essential to consider how the fear and resultant actions of the character serve to advance the story’s themes and the writer’s intent.

User Sharareh
by
7.8k points