56.6k views
0 votes
You meet three inhabitants: Zippy, Betty and Sally. Zippy tells you that Sally and Betty are different. Betty says that it's false that Sally is a knave. Sally tells you that Zippy is a knave. Who is a knight and who is a knave?

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

In the logical puzzle presented, Zippy and Betty are knaves, and Sally is a knight, as deduced by analyzing their statements and applying the definitions of knights and knaves.

Step-by-step explanation:

The logical puzzle presented involves determining who is a knight (one who always tells the truth) and who is a knave (one who always lies) based on their statements. Zippy states that Sally and Betty are different. If Zippy were a knight, one would be a knight and the other a knave.

Conversely, if Zippy were a knave, Sally and Betty would both be of the same type. Betty claims that it is false that Sally is a knave; if Betty is a knight, then Sally is also a knight. If Betty were a knave, her statement would falsely indicate that Sally is a knight, meaning Sally would be a knave.

Lastly, Sally states that Zippy is a knave. If Sally were a knight, then her statement would be true, confirming that Zippy is a knave. If Sally were a knave, she would be lying, indicating that Zippy is a knight.

By analyzing these statements, it becomes clear that Zippy is a knave, Betty is a knave, and Sally is a knight. This solution aligns with all the statements when considering the nature of knights and knaves.

User Mitesh
by
7.4k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.