56.6k views
0 votes
You meet three inhabitants: Zippy, Betty and Sally. Zippy tells you that Sally and Betty are different. Betty says that it's false that Sally is a knave. Sally tells you that Zippy is a knave. Who is a knight and who is a knave?

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

In the logical puzzle presented, Zippy and Betty are knaves, and Sally is a knight, as deduced by analyzing their statements and applying the definitions of knights and knaves.

Step-by-step explanation:

The logical puzzle presented involves determining who is a knight (one who always tells the truth) and who is a knave (one who always lies) based on their statements. Zippy states that Sally and Betty are different. If Zippy were a knight, one would be a knight and the other a knave.

Conversely, if Zippy were a knave, Sally and Betty would both be of the same type. Betty claims that it is false that Sally is a knave; if Betty is a knight, then Sally is also a knight. If Betty were a knave, her statement would falsely indicate that Sally is a knight, meaning Sally would be a knave.

Lastly, Sally states that Zippy is a knave. If Sally were a knight, then her statement would be true, confirming that Zippy is a knave. If Sally were a knave, she would be lying, indicating that Zippy is a knight.

By analyzing these statements, it becomes clear that Zippy is a knave, Betty is a knave, and Sally is a knight. This solution aligns with all the statements when considering the nature of knights and knaves.

User Mitesh
by
7.3k points