56.5k views
0 votes
technician a says drum brake disadvantages include poorer heat dissipation and less fade resistance than disc brakes. technician b says drum brake disadvantages include lack of self-adjustment without special linkage, and a greater tendency than disc brakes to pull and grab. who is correct?

User Jjxtra
by
7.3k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

Both Technician A and Technician B are correct regarding the disadvantages of drum brakes: poor heat dissipation leading to brake fade and the lack of self-adjustment leading to inconsistent braking.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question poses a scenario discussing the disadvantages of drum brakes compared to disc brakes. Both Technician A and Technician B make claims about the drawbacks of drum brakes. Technician A says that drum brakes have poorer heat dissipation and less fade resistance than disc brakes. Technician B says that drum brakes lack self-adjustment without special linkage and have a greater tendency than disc brakes to pull and grab.

Technician A's statement is correct because drum brakes are enclosed, which impedes heat dissipation, leading to higher temperatures and a higher likelihood of brake fade during intensive use such as prolonged downhill driving. This is significant, as poor heat dissipation can lead to overheating, as when the brakes of a truck become visibly smoking due to the mechanical equivalent of heat, converting kinetic and potential energy into thermal energy in the brake material.

Technician B's observation is also correct; drum brakes generally require a self-adjusting mechanism to maintain proper shoe-to-drum clearance as the brakes wear. Without it, they do not self-adjust like disc brakes. Furthermore, improper adjustment or wear can lead to inconsistencies in braking force, causing the vehicle to pull to one side or experience brake 'grab.'

User Csum
by
8.0k points