Question

Many historians describe the American relationship with Native Americans as "paternalistic," signifying that America considered itself the "father" of the Native Americans, whom they deemed as "children" needing civilization and instruction in modern ways. Does Captain Lewis appear to express this viewpoint? Provide evidence from the text to support your claims.

Answer 1

The American relationship with Native Americans was often seen as paternalistic, and Captain Lewis's interactions with Native Americans had elements of paternalism, but not all interactions were peaceful.

Step-by-step explanation:

Many historians describe the American relationship with Native Americans as "paternalistic," signifying that America considered itself the "father" of the Native Americans, whom they deemed as "children" needing civilization and instruction in modern ways. In the case of Captain Lewis, there are instances where he appears to express this viewpoint.

For example, the Lewis and Clark expedition sought to assert American power over Native American territories while also presenting gifts as a sign of goodwill. However, not all interactions went peacefully, as tensions arose with some tribes, leading to violence. This supports the idea that the paternalistic viewpoint was not consistently upheld.