197k views
2 votes
If the United States, Mexico, and Canada considered forming a North American Union like the European Union, what are two potential setbacks or hurdles they might face, drawing from your knowledge of the EU?

User Harrymc
by
7.5k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

Potential setbacks for a North American Union like the EU include economic pressures on member states leading to 'Euroskeptic' sentiment and challenges aligning environmental and labor regulations impacting legislation effectiveness and job markets.

Step-by-step explanation:

If the United States, Mexico, and Canada considered forming a North American Union similar to the European Union, two potential setbacks or hurdles they might face could be related to the experiences of the EU. Firstly, there might be economic pressures on national governments, which can lessen the advantages perceived by member states, particularly if wealthier states feel they are subsidizing poorer ones. This can lead to a loss of sovereign identity and contribute to 'Euroskeptic' sentiment, resulting in discord and even withdrawal from the union, as seen with the UK's Brexit. A second setback could arise from differing levels of regulatory and protective legislation, such as environmental and labor laws. Concerns similar to those expressed by environmentalists and labor unions during the NAFTA discussions could resurface, potentially reducing the effectiveness of such legislation and impacting jobs and corporate decisions about relocation.

User BrodieG
by
7.3k points