146k views
3 votes
Did the constitution form a more perfect union than the articles of confederation

User Auburg
by
8.9k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The Constitution succeeded in forming a "more perfect union" by addressing the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation, creating a stronger federal government, and maintaining the sovereignty of the states. It implemented a system of checks and balances and provided the federal government with the authority to tax, draft troops, and enforce laws, elements absent in the Articles, contributing to a more stable and unified nation.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the summer of 1787, the United States faced a pivotal moment in the formation of its national government. The Articles of Confederation had created a loose association of states, each heavily protective of its own sovereignty, which led to a fragmented national identity.

Recognizing the limitations and ineffectiveness of the Confederation Congress, which could not enforce laws, tax, or maintain a standing army, leaders called for a convention to address these issues. Thus, the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia resulted in the drafting of a new framework, the United States Constitution, which aimed to rectify the weaknesses of the Articles by establishing a stronger central government while still preserving the rights of states.

The Constitution introduced a balance of power between the states and the federal government, resolving conflicts that arose from regional and state interests. It provided for a separate judicial branch, the right for the federal government to tax, draft troops, and a system of checks and balances to prevent any one branch from becoming too powerful. The "more perfect union" sought by the framers was indeed achieved through these measures, strengthening the national government's ability to act on behalf of the collective interests of the states, thus ensuring a more unified nation.

The success of the Constitution over the Articles of Confederation is demonstrable in the stability and longevity it has provided the United States as a nation. While the Articles represented an initial attempt at unifying the former colonies, the Constitution realized a more robust and effective framework for governance, facilitating the growth and prosperity of the country.

User NOZUONOHIGH
by
9.0k points

No related questions found