148k views
0 votes
How do we know that mistrals writing was not motivated solely by monetary considerations?

a) Mistrals explicitly stated non-monetary motivations.
b) Historical records reveal diverse influences on Mistrals' writing.
c) Mistrals' writing lacked any commercial success.
d) Critics unanimously agree on the non-monetary motivation.

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Historical records and textual analysis indicate that Mistrals' writing motivations likely included a mix of societal, cultural, and personal beliefs, not solely monetary considerations. Incidents of non-consensual publication further suggest that commerce was not the only influence in literature's creation and dissemination. option b is the correct answer.

Step-by-step explanation:

We can understand the motivations behind Mistrals' writing by considering several factors rather than assuming a sole concern for monetary benefit. Historical records may reveal diverse influences that shaped Mistrals' work, such as societal, cultural, or personal beliefs. Textual analysis plays a critical role in interpreting the motives behind a writer's work, which is evident by looking at the structure, themes, and context. For example, Jeann-Jacques Glassner believed that early writing was more than just an accounting method, suggesting a deeper, more intellectual motivation behind it. Furthermore, unintended publication incidents, like that which befell Henry King's writings, highlight that commercial success isn't the only factor influencing the creation and dissemination of literature.

While critics' opinions can offer insights into an author's intentions, these are not definitive evidence of an author's motivation. Similarly, although monetary gain can be a driving force for some writers, others may be compelled by the need to communicate, influence, or create art. Therefore, when assessing the reasons Mistrals might have had for writing, it’s important not to simplify the impetus to solely economic factors without a thorough investigation into the context and evidence surrounding Mistrals' work.

User Achoukah
by
6.8k points