Final answer:
The best scenario describing the consensual reflex is when light causes constriction in both pupils regardless of only one eye being stimulated, demonstrating the bilateral nature of the pupillary light reflex.
Step-by-step explanation:
The scenario that best describes the consensual reflex is: C. You sit in a dimly-lit room with your hand covering one eye so that no light enters. You switch on a light, causing constriction of the pupils of both the covered and uncovered eye. The pupillary light reflex is an example of autonomic control where the pupils constrict or dilate in response to the amount of light hitting the retina. When light hits the retina in one eye, both pupils contract due to a parasympathetic response through the oculomotor nerve, and when the light is removed, both pupils dilate back to their resting position. This response illustrates how the autonomic reflexes, controlled by the hypothalamus and other CNS locations, differ from somatic reflexes, which are unilateral or affect only the stimulated side.