Hindenburg's objections and the groups he advocated for reveal that he believed in a universe of obligation built on loyalty, experience, service, and commitment. He prioritized those who had dedicated themselves to the nation, whether through military service or government work, and believed they deserved protection and respect.
Hindenburg's Objection to the Civil Service Law
President Paul von Hindenburg's specific objection to the proposed Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service was that it unfairly targeted and dismissed certain groups of civil servants without due process. He demanded amendments to the bill before he would approve it.
Here are the specific groups he advocated for:
World War I veterans who had served at the front: Hindenburg believed these veterans deserved protection for their service and sacrifice to Germany. He likely saw them as loyal citizens who had already proven their dedication to the nation.
Civil servants who had been employed for a long period of time: Hindenburg argued that these individuals possessed valuable experience and institutional knowledge that would be lost if they were dismissed. He likely believed their expertise was critical for the smooth functioning of the government.
Civil servants who were close to retirement: Hindenburg argued that dismissing these individuals shortly before their retirement age would deprive them of their earned pensions and inflict undue hardship. He likely saw this as a violation of their rights and a betrayal of their service.
Hindenburg's Universe of Obligation
Hindenburg's letter indicates that he believed the following groups deserved protection as part of Germany's universe of obligation:
Those who served in the military, especially veterans of World War I: This suggests he held military service in high regard and saw it as a key element of national identity and obligation.
Those who had dedicated their lives to public service: This indicates that he valued experience and expertise in government and believed these individuals were vital for the country's well-being.
Those who had earned their retirement benefits: This suggests he believed in the importance of honoring commitments and providing for those who had served the nation faithfully.
Question
what was hindenburg's specific objection to the proposed civil service service law? what does hindenburg's letter indicate about who he believed should be protected as part of germany's universe of obligation?