132k views
3 votes
The nurse is researching the use of music therapy for patients with dementia and finds that many research articles have been

published about the topic. Which single source will provide the best evidence for the nurse?
a. The opinion of an expert committee
b. Meta-analysis of randomized control trials
c. One well-designed randomized control trial
d. Systematic review of qualitative nursing studies

User BHuelse
by
8.6k points

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

A meta-analysis of randomized control trials would provide the best evidence for the use of music therapy in dementia patients, due to its comprehensive analysis and synthesis of data from multiple studies, resulting in higher statistical power.

Step-by-step explanation:

The best evidence for a nurse researching the use of music therapy for patients with dementia would be a meta-analysis of randomized control trials. This is because a meta-analysis compiles data from several studies to provide a larger data set, which increases the statistical power and improves the precision of the overall conclusions. By comparing and combining results from various studies, a meta-analysis can offer a high level of evidence, above that provided by individual studies or expert opinions. It is an essential tool for evidence-based practice in medicine and healthcare.

In contrast, while a single randomized control trial is a valuable source and a systematic review of qualitative nursing studies or the opinion of an expert committee provides insights, they do not encompass the same breadth of analysis and aggregation of data that a meta-analysis does. Systematic reviews are also valuable, but they may include a broader range of study designs and may not always synthesize data quantitatively, as a meta-analysis does.

User Nuthinking
by
7.3k points