219k views
4 votes
According to Aristotle, what is the vicious man no longer capable of understanding?

2 Answers

4 votes

Answer:

Aristotle believed that a vicious man can no longer understand virtue or noble actions, as his character and moral compass are deeply corrupted. This moral blindness is likened to Plato's allegory of the cave, where the vicious man is unable to see moral truths that are evident to the virtuous person.

Step-by-step explanation:

According to Aristotle, the vicious man loses the capacity to understand or comprehend the very nature of virtue and the good; his character has been corrupted to such an extent that he cannot even desire the truly noble things in life. Aristotle posits that through habitual engagement in vice, a person's ability to recognize virtuous actions deteriorates, and as such, their moral compass is fundamentally compromised. They are no longer capable of seeing the goodness of virtuous actions or the badness of vices, and thus cannot be guided by the moral truths that virtuous people recognize and live by.

The process of moral decline described by Aristotle is akin to the allegory depicted by Socrates in Plato’s 'Republic,' where a person accustomed to the dark cannot immediately recognize or understand the realities when brought into the light. In this context, the vicious man, akin to a prisoner in a cave, is blinded by his vices and cannot see the moral truths that are as glaring as the sun to the virtuous person. It’s a state of moral blindness wherein the ability to discern right from wrong is severely incapacitated.

In summary, for Aristotle, the ultimate harm is not physical but moral, where the character of a person is so damaged that they can no longer distinguish good from evil, just as someone might be physically unable to see in conditions of extreme light or darkness after a lifetime of residing in the shadows.

User Tony Day
by
7.9k points
4 votes

Final Answer:

According to Aristotle, the vicious man is incapable of understanding the true nature of virtue and the path to a virtuous life. Hindered by moral deficiencies, he fails to grasp the concept of eudaimonia, or true flourishing, and remains disconnected from the fulfillment derived from virtuous actions. In essence, the vicious person lacks insight into the genuine good and happiness found in a morally upright existence.

Step-by-step explanation:

According to Aristotle, the vicious man is no longer capable of understanding the truly good and virtuous life. In Aristotle's ethical philosophy, virtue is central to the concept of eudaimonia, which is often translated as "flourishing" or "the good life."

The vicious person, due to their moral deficiencies and bad habits, lacks the proper understanding and insight into what constitutes true happiness and a life of virtue.Aristotle argues that virtue involves finding the mean between extremes, and the vicious person is one who has strayed too far from this mean.

Such an individual is unable to appreciate and understand the value of virtuous actions and the fulfillment that comes from living a morally good life. The vicious person is caught in a cycle of harmful behaviors and desires, making it difficult for them to grasp the higher ideals of virtue and the genuine well-being that accompanies a virtuous life.

User Maiasaura
by
8.3k points