Question

Which excerpt from Sullivan’s article best reflects a tone that is critical toward Faulkner’s authorial decisions?

A. Not to have failed completely at such a task is indistinguishable from triumph.
B. In a series of halting exchanges, Quentin tries to answer, about the South and what it does to people.
C. The September afternoon on which the book opens in a "dim hot airless" room is described as "long still hot weary dead."
D. He tells us on the third page (in italics) pretty much everything that will happen in the book, actionwise.

Answer 1

Option D from Sullivan's article reflects the most critical tone towards Faulkner's authorial decisions, as it comments on his technique of revealing the plot early on in the narrative.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question asks which excerpt from Sullivan’s article most critically reflects on William Faulkner’s authorial decisions. Examining each option:

• Option A is more complimentary, equating Faulkner's attempt with triumph.

• Option B describes a scene from the narrative, not a critical perspective on Faulkner's writing.

• Option C sets a scene's mood but doesn't offer a critique of Faulkner's authorial choices.

• Option D directly addresses Faulkner's narrative approach, highlighting a decision to reveal the plot early on, which can be read as a critical remark on his storytelling technique. Therefore, option D is the correct answer as it reflects a critical tone towards how Faulkner handles plot revelation.