Question

Is this statement logically flawed? "Democrats aren't logical; they think with their hearts and not their heads." Which statement below is correct?

a) Yes, this is an ad hominem attack. It is a personal attack that is designed to sidetrack the substance of the discussion with an insult.
b) Yes, this is a historian's fallacy. It assumes people in the past had the same information that we do now.
c) No, this is a solid argument based on inductive reasoning.
d) No, this is a solid argument based on deductive reasoning.

Answer 1

The statement is an ad hominem attack because it attempts to discredit Democrats by attacking their personal characteristic of emotional thinking rather than their arguments.

Step-by-step explanation:

The statement "Democrats aren't logical; they think with their hearts and not their heads" is logically flawed. The correct answer to whether this statement is logically flawed is:

a) Yes, this is an

ad hominem

attack.

It is a personal attack designed to sidetrack the substance of the discussion with an insult. Rather than addressing an actual argument or presenting evidence, it attempts to discredit a group of people by attacking their personal characteristics, implying they are not logical due to their emotional thinking. This is a classic logical fallacy known as an ad hominem attack, which targets the individual rather than their ideas or arguments.