Final answer:
Mrs. Rogers made the Kool-Aid unsaturated by adding only half the recommended sugar, leading to a Kool-Aid mixture with less sweetness than the standard, which explains why Mr. Rogers finds the taste to be 'not right'.
Step-by-step explanation:
Mr. Rogers, the reason the Kool-Aid does not taste 'right' to you is likely due to the difference in sugar concentration that Mrs. Rogers used. The package instructions called for 1 cup of sugar, which gives a certain expected sweetness and flavor profile. Since Mrs. Rogers only added ½ cup of sugar, the resulting Kool-Aid is unsaturated with sugar compared to the standard recipe, essentially having a lower solute concentration. This means there is less sugar dissolved in the Kool-Aid than what the water can potentially dissolve, giving it a less sweet taste than you might expect.