124k views
5 votes
How does Schatz handle his "illness"? Explain how his approach is both good and bad. Cite specific evidence from the text to support your answer. 5 sentence minimum response

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

In 'A Day's Wait' by Ernest Hemingway, Schatz handles his 'illness' by believing he has a high temperature, showing responsibility but also vulnerability. Specific evidence from the text supports both the good and bad aspects of his approach.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the short story 'A Day's Wait' by Ernest Hemingway, Schatz handles his 'illness' by believing that he has a temperature of 104 degrees Fahrenheit when in reality, he has misunderstood the temperature reading on the thermometer. Schatz's approach can be seen as both good and bad.

On one hand, his approach is good because he shows a sense of responsibility and maturity in taking care of himself. He insists on staying in bed and taking medicine to get better. This shows his strong determination to take care of his own health.

On the other hand, his approach is bad because he does not seek clarification or communicate his concerns with his father. This lack of communication leads to unnecessary worry and stress for both Schatz and his father. Furthermore, it highlights Schatz's vulnerability and misunderstanding of the situation.

Specific evidence from the text that supports Schatz's approach being good is when he tells his father, 'I guess I'm alright.' This shows his belief that he can handle the situation on his own. However, evidence that supports his approach being bad is shown when his father says, 'If I'd felt that way when I was a kid I'd have been an invalid my whole life.' This indicates that Schatz's approach is not age-appropriate or well-informed.

User Jim Wrubel
by
7.5k points