145k views
2 votes
Legislation always, sometimes,never, represents the need and desire of American people what is your evidence

User SumNeuron
by
7.7k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

Legislation sometimes represents the needs and desires of the American people; however, it often supports the interests of the wealthy due to their influence through lobbying and model legislation. Despite this, historical examples show that legislation can lead to significant positive changes, reflecting the will of the people at times.

Step-by-step explanation:

Legislation does not always represent the needs and desires of the American people. This is evidenced by research conducted by political scientist Martin Gilens, who found that government policy often supports the views of the wealthy over those of poor or middle-class Americans.

Furthermore, lobbying groups and wealthy individuals can exert disproportionate influence on legislation through the use of think tanks, legislative consulting groups, and the promotion of 'model legislation.' As a consequence, laws can sometimes reflect the interests of a narrow group of people rather than the broader electorate.

However, legislation can sometimes represent national mood and political culture, as legislators in a representative democracy or republic are tasked with creating and passing laws that protect or benefit the public. Historical examples like the voting rights reforms, affirmative action, and the end to segregation illustrate how governmental policies have brought about positive changes for American citizens.

Yet the debate on the representation in government and the efficacy of the democratic process persists, underscoring the complexity of the relationship between legislation and public will.

User Gevorg
by
7.6k points