32.6k views
4 votes
In the conversation about Lady Brett Ashley in "The Sun Also Rises," what is Jake's view of her? What is Cohn's? How do you explain the difference?

A) Jake sees Brett as independent, while Cohn sees her as traditional. The difference is due to their backgrounds.
B) Jake is indifferent to Brett, while Cohn is infatuated with her. The difference is due to their personalities.
C) Jake sees Brett as unattainable, while Cohn sees her as a potential partner. The difference is due to their romantic interests.
D) Jake and Cohn both view Brett positively, and there is no difference between their views.

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Jake views Lady Brett Ashley as unattainable due to his situation, while Cohn, infatuated, sees her as a potential romantic partner. The difference in their perspectives is rooted in their individual romantic interests and personal experiences. The accurate answer reflecting their views is Option C.

Step-by-step explanation:

In The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway, Jake views Lady Brett Ashley as a complex figure who embodies independence but also represents a love he cannot fulfill due to his war injury.

His view is marred with resignation over the impossibility of their romance. On the other hand, Cohn is deeply infatuated with Lady Brett, seeing her as a romantic interest that is attainable and idealizing her despite her clear autonomy and the complexity of her relationships with other men.

The difference in Jake's and Cohn's views of Brett stems largely from their experiences and emotions. Jake's injury and history with Brett give him a more mature and pained perspective, whereas Cohn's infatuation and lack of similar experiences lead him to a more naive view. Thus, when analyzing their outlooks on Brett, one can conclude that it is their respective romantic interests and personal histories that shape their differing perceptions.

The correct option that explains Jake's and Cohn's differing views is C) Jake sees Brett as unattainable, while Cohn sees her as a potential partner. The difference is due to their romantic interests.

User Caligari
by
8.7k points