209k views
2 votes
Is it fair for Montag to go after the other firemen? Explain your reasoning with evidence from the text.

User Skimedic
by
7.7k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

In 'Fahrenheit 451', it can be argued that it is fair for Montag to go after the other firemen because they uphold a system that suppresses knowledge and individuality. Montag holds the other firemen responsible for allowing him to engage in destructive actions without realizing the significance of books. He questions their authority and seeks to express his individuality.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the novel 'Fahrenheit 451' by Ray Bradbury, it can be argued that it is fair for Montag to go after the other firemen. Montag's role as a fireman is to burn books, which goes against his newfound realization that books hold valuable knowledge and ideas. He sees the other firemen as complicit in a system that suppresses knowledge and individuality, making it reasonable for him to take action against them.

One piece of evidence from the text is when Montag exclaims, 'Why did you let me do it a dozen times before telling me?' He is referring to the times he burnt books without realizing their significance. This suggests that Montag holds the other firemen responsible for allowing him to engage in destructive actions without questioning them. Another piece of evidence is when Montag asks Beatty, 'What did the Founding Fathers really say? I bet it's got something to do with the First Amendment.' Here, Montag reveals his growing curiosity about the ideas contained in books and his desire to express his individuality. By questioning the actions of the other firemen, Montag is challenging their authority and seeking to break free from the oppressive society they uphold.

User Sagar Ranglani
by
7.6k points